Gotta say, I agree wholeheartedly with Keith about the summaries. That certainly is a factor for me even clicking a story link. If the story describes via its tags something I'm not interested in, I DON'T read it. It can and should be that simple.
As a reader, I rarely review. When I do it's not much of one other than I liked what I read, and generally pointing out something I particularly liked about a chapter or something.
As a mod, however, people may in fact see a review from me, or any other mod, pointing out something that needs correction. That's different than reading the story, and has not a damn thing to do with it. Having said that, I can also say that AS A MOD, if I find I cannot be objective and impartial in a particular for instance, I defer it to someone else. It's the only way to do it, really. So, for example, with some objections I've seen raised with Kip's story (and there really haven't been that many) because it's subject matter I find I cannot be objective about, inquiries have been sent to other mods to handle.