@GG: Plot and title suggest a proper stand-alone episode at some time during S01-S04. I'd read it.
Is this thread just for proclaiming or should others feel encouraged to offer opinions and suggestions so the story might work after all?
Working title: Not Human at all
Fandom: Buffy the Vampire Slayer
Plot: S04 What if...
Starts with "Living Conditions". The Initiative coincidentally finds out about Willow's witchiness, abducts and confines her in its facility. They fake her death, remove uterus and oviducts, shave her hair and implant a chip similar to Spike's. They consider her not human and want to use her abilities for their own purposes. Walsh is the main meanie here. Riley is one of her captors but eventually turns from abettor to her only connection to the outer world as well as the only one who treats her human. At the end, he's a crucial element to her liberation.
Willow herself develops from plain victim to her own rescuer. The others believe her death until Riley, who started to date Buffy here as well, tells them the truth.
Supposed to be an alternate S04, where every character gets his/her adequate attention and the canon main topics are somehow merged in.
Fatal flaw: Everything! It was foredoomed from the beginning. Story is too big and advanced for a beginner and I didn't thought it through. After two chapters it was like "Errm, yeah. What comes next?" The bright side is that I really started to think about what it means to write a story with everything involved instead of having the "Ha! It just will work out somehow." mindset. The project is on hiatus now until I've gained more experience and skill by writing shortfics with much simpler demands.