Always fascinated and wrote about wrong pairings. What's your ultimate wrong pairing?

[Itwasmerlin]

Hi guys Merlin here . 

I've always liked and wrote about wrong pairings. Most non con and blackmail . Hypnosis 

Older-younger

Looser/hottie etc 

Not always wrong in real life but in tv shows etc when you know the characters you'd know it's not normal. Especially with tone and other love interests.

Not sure if this is the right part to post about this. But in TV, movies, games etc what is your favourite wrong couples you'd love to see adult fics written about.  For example I've done 

Hitchcock/Rosa b99

Astrid Hofferson/Mildew how to train your dragon

Sarah Walker/Morgan grimes in chuck 

And more.  

So what's your ideal, wrong pairing ? And why? 

 

[GeorgeGlass]

Jeez, where do I even start?

As wrong pairings go, I loves me some incest. I’ve written stories about Hiro and his Aunt Cass from Big Hero 6, Dipper and Mabel from Gravity Falls, and Lincoln Loud and virtually all of his sisters from The Loud House.

[Wilde_Guess]

Hi, all.

For truly “wrong” romantic/erotic parings, I tend to go towards dark humor.  So, Dipper/Mabel isn’t quite a “wrong” pairing, though it raises the question that if they married in Kentucky and divorced in Arkansas, would they still be fraternal twins.  I’m thinking more along the lines of Mr. Ed/receptive Wilbur, Granny/Mr. Drysdale, Uncle Joe/every female over the age of consent, etc.

Cheers!

[InvidiaRed]

I think the most messed up one I found was Umbridge X Neville. 

[GeorgeGlass]

On 8/23/2025 at 7:05 PM, InvidiaRed said:

I think the most messed up one I found was Umbridge X Neville. 

Yikes. 

[JayDee]

The Monster Under The Bed x My Sleep Paralysis Demon (Those fucking squelching noises, I swear, it’s grim folks, grim).

 

[InBrightestDay]

On 9/1/2025 at 1:10 PM, JayDee said:

The Monster Under The Bed x My Sleep Paralysis Demon (Those fucking squelching noises, I swear, it’s grim folks, grim).

 

And they’re rude enough to only get it on when you’re in the bed right above them.  *shakes head* No class at all…

As for me, depending on what you consider “wrong,” I may have never written a right pairing. 😅  My established pairings have an extreme age difference, to put it mildly (18-20 year old man and immortal women centuries to eons old), and I’m working on a brother/sister incest pairing.

As for why, it’s a bit difficult to explain.  When it comes to the extreme age differences between human/nonhuman characters, there are published authors who write stuff like that (see the popular A Court of Thorns and Roses series), but to get down to why it appeals to me, I think it’s a fantasy I have as a man who’s always been unsure of himself, especially with women, and there is a fantasy of a shy, nervous young man being introduced to sex by a knowledgeable older woman.  Kevin/Luzurial doesn’t exactly fit that mold since they’re both inexperienced regardless of age, but the other examples do, including the incest story (older sister/younger brother).  The “why” on the incest pairings is somewhat more complex; I’ll return to that when I have time.

Edited yesterday at 04:34 PM by InBrightestDay

[BronxWench]

Given my predilection for CRPGs  set in the D&D/Forgotten Realms ‘verse, probably my favorite “wrong” pairing was a series of fan fictions with Sand x Torio (Neverwinter Nights 2). That was definitely off the normal radar, but honestly, so well written that it worked.  

Then there was a mod written for Baldur’s Gate/Shadows of Amn, where the PC gets to romance their nemesis from the original game, their half-brother Sarevok, who spent the entire original game trying to kill the PC so he could absorb the power of their father, the dead god of murder, Bhaal. It was a major enemies to lovers twist, but again, well written enough to work.

I’m not sure I’ve ever managed to write anything so spectacularly wrong and yet as perfect as those two…  *sighs* 

[Deadman]

I don’t know that historically I’ve done much in the wrong pairing. However, I have a couple stories, one of which is posted here.

My “wrong pairing” has been in the Buffy fandom I wrote a story that includes Dawn/Buffy/Faith/Joyce.

Not necessarily a pairing but I have done gangbang stories obviously which could theoretically be a “wrong pairing”.

There are a couple stories in which things got seriously dark but they aren’t really anywhere for people to read at the moment.
 

[GeorgeGlass]

1 hour ago, Deadman said:

My “wrong pairing” has been in the Buffy fandom I wrote a story that includes Dawn/Buffy/Faith/Joyce.

Oh, my. Can you still call it a pairing when there are 4+ people involved? Because if you can, than my Star Vs. the Forces of Evil pairing is Marco/Star/Jackie/Janna/Princess Arms/Kelly/Hekapoo/Brittney/Higgs/Starfan13.

No, seriously, I wrote that one.

[Deadman]

20 hours ago, GeorgeGlass said:

Oh, my. Can you still call it a pairing when there are 4+ people involved? Because if you can, than my Star Vs. the Forces of Evil pairing is Marco/Star/Jackie/Janna/Princess Arms/Kelly/Hekapoo/Brittney/Higgs/Starfan13.

No, seriously, I wrote that one.

Well that’s the curious point. Would a thruple qualify as a pairing? The same story I have Dawn/Buffy/Faith. A few other types of pairings too but they’re not out yet.

In the Riverdale fandom, I have a pairing coming up involving Cheryl/Betty. Although they aren’t exclusive.