Inshadowsidream Posted June 10, 2019 Report Posted June 10, 2019 A friend of mine decided to try her hand at writing and asked me a question I couldn't answer. If you don't want the gender of a character to give clues as to their identy, how do you go about hiding it? Her protagonist is being helped by an unknown person, a person with fair hair. All her character sees is this person from the back, and since they wears baggy clothes, the gender isn't clear. If she types "blonde" it gives away the gender, if she uses "blond" it misleads the reader into believing it is a male helping out, which would later be discovered to be a lie. She wants to keep the reader guessing, but with the gender specific spellings, that is proving impossible. After reading what she has written so far, I agree, using "fair haired person" or a variance, is awkward in many of the situations. BronxWench 1 Quote
JayDee Posted June 10, 2019 Report Posted June 10, 2019 She could go with an establishing narration that the gender is unclear, followed by constructions like “The blond\e” or “s\he ran”, or just have the original fair haired thing and then after that go for non gendered descriptors like “stranger” or “helper” or “helpful stranger” similar. BronxWench, Mina-chan95 and InvidiaRed 3 Quote
BronxWench Posted June 10, 2019 Report Posted June 10, 2019 If the name is ambiguous, using the character’s name is also a way around things. JayDee and InvidiaRed 2 Quote
Thundercloud Posted June 10, 2019 Report Posted June 10, 2019 If it is important that the gender is uncertain then I propose it is best to show that the watcher is uncertain of the gender and not hope the reader gets this. BronxWench and JayDee 2 Quote
InvidiaRed Posted June 10, 2019 Report Posted June 10, 2019 6 hours ago, JayDee said: She could go with an establishing narration that the gender is unclear, followed by constructions like “The blond\e” or “s\he ran”, or just have the original fair haired thing and then after that go for non gendered descriptors like “stranger” or “helper” or “helpful stranger” similar. Yes. This is one of the best ways. They/Them could work. You don’t want to use the word “it” . Cause it a dehumanizing in a sense but also the least informative word to give. Unless the character isn't human at all. JayDee and BronxWench 2 Quote
Inshadowsidream Posted June 10, 2019 Author Report Posted June 10, 2019 Thank you all. I had no idea how to handle it as I have never tried writing something that required the gender of a person being concealed. This is why I came back, the people here are so willing to help. It is so nice. BronxWench, InvidiaRed and JayDee 3 Quote
CloverReef Posted June 19, 2019 Report Posted June 19, 2019 (edited) There are genderless nouns that could be used in place of a name if the name is unknown. “The stranger”, “The figure”, or for example, using a nickname, like if she described them as ghostlike, then calling them the ‘phantom’, or something more in line with the narrator’s personality. Sorry, I’m sticking my nose in late to the convo but I do love to hear myself type! Edited June 19, 2019 by CloverReef BronxWench, InvidiaRed, JayDee and 1 other 4 Quote
Desiderius Price Posted December 12, 2020 Report Posted December 12, 2020 Well, if it’s fanfiction w/o a beta reader, one could get away with mixing up the two terms “blonde” and “blond” every several sentences A quick check of the thesaurus gives “fair”, “light”, “bleached”, “flaxen”, “sandy-haired”, or “yellow-haired” as synonyms as possible alternatives. But, yeah, that’d be my approach, check the thesaurus for non-gender synonyms to substitute during the descriptions. (I’m writing a fic where I’ve got a similar issue, though not in gender.) InvidiaRed 1 Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.