Review Topic: Cheryl's Cherry Collection

[Deadman]

Author: Deadman
Title: Cheryl’s Cherry Collection
Summary: After Toni leaves her for her crazy behavior, Cheryl decides to satisfy her sexual needs elsewhere. Cheryl decides to build a collection of cherries from the the women of Riverdale.
Feedback: Happy to have feedback or suggestions.
Fandom: Riverdale
Pairing: FemSlash-Female/Female
Warnings: 3Plus AFFO Anal Angst Ds Exhib FF Fingering Oral PWP Solo Spank UST Voy WIP
Solo story or chaptered story: This is a multi chaptered story.
URL: https://tv.adult-fanfiction.org/story.php?no=600100068

[Deadman]

Quote

@SapphicRobot:

What a lovely surprise! Glad to see that Riverdale erotica content is not dead. The universe is just so ripe for it! Your gangbang series is one of my all time favorites and I'm sad it won't be continued, there was still so much potential for those stories if you ask me!

Really hoping we get some rough strap-on content in this, as well as some fisting, double-dildoes, anal, and tons of squirting!

May I ask who is the next one lucky enough to get Cheryl'd? I'd love to see her resort to manipulation, trickery, blackmail, etc. doing and saying whatever she needs to to get in a woman's pants.

Fingers crossed as well for a Katy Keene chapter, a Donna Sweett chapter, and a Sabrina Spellman one!

Thank you so much for saying such wonderful things about my gangbang series and that you’re reading this new one. Fun fact, I have a Riverdale story coming up that’s kind’ve a spinoff of one of the gangbang chapters.

Definitely agree that the Riverdale universe is ripe for all kinds of erotica. I have one other piece that I have been writing for after this in the Riverdale universe.

As for who’s going to be “Cheryl’d” next, you can ask but I’m not going to say just to keep the mystery alive. The more reviews I get on my Riverdale stories the more I might just focus on those. Maybe there will be a sequel or two depending on how people react.

 

Edited April 15 by Deadman

[Deadman]

Chapter 2 is up

Caramel Cherry

Summary: After the success of Cheryl’s time with Betty, Veronica happens upon Cheryl having some fun and ends up becoming Cheryl’s next target.

https://tv.adult-fanfiction.org/story.php?no=600100068&chapter=2

 

 

[Deadman]

Chapter 3 is up

Dark Chocolate Cherry

Summary: With Cheryl enjoying both Betty and Veronica as playthings, Cheryl goes after Josie.

https://tv.adult-fanfiction.org/story.php?no=600100068&chapter=3

Edited June 8 by Deadman

[Deadman]

Chapter 4 is up

Vanilla Caramel Swirl

Summary: Betty and Veronica try to confront Cheryl over what she’s done, but Cheryl has other ideas.

https://tv.adult-fanfiction.org/story.php?no=600100068&chapter=4

[Deadman]

Chapter 5 is up

Hot Tamale

Summary: With all the cherries in place, Cheryl has one more to add to her collection… Toni.

https://tv.adult-fanfiction.org/story.php?no=600100068&chapter=5

[Deadman]

Chapter 6 is up

Swirl

Summary: Cheryl’s collection is complete. Now she wants to have some fun with them.

https://tv.adult-fanfiction.org/story.php?no=600100068&chapter=6

[Deadman]

 

Quote

 

SapphicRobot

September 12, 2026 at 12:00 AM

Always a delight to see new chapters here! The double dildo battle was amazing. Are you planning more chapters or has this concluded? Would still love to see Sabrina Spellman, Katy Keene, and Donna Sweett feature, plus some strap-on usage! 

 

Thanks so much for liking the story.

I do have a sequel idea in my head for this that was teased in the Josie chapter. But I hadn’t planned on it involving Sabrina, Katy or Donna. Maybe if the idea occurs to me, I’ll consider doing a sequel.

For now, I’m moving on to another Riverdale focused fanfic that I’m almost finished with. Hoping to have it done by the time the first chapter is posted. This one will need to have the chapters split up into multiple parts. Just to give people less to read per chapter. I worry it’s too long at the moment to post each chapter fully.