Jump to content

Click Here!

maxlength in edit vs add


EllieMorgan

Recommended Posts

Adding a new story has the summary box with maxlength 240 plus multi select to append relevant tags. Editing a description (to, for example, append new tags) has the combined summary+tag field limited to 255, resulting in being unable to update without removing portions of summary (one of my stories has, for example, 130ish chars of tags).

When I say "unable", I mean that bypassing maxlength in edit form submission (attribute deletion on browser end etc) allowed the tags to be edited without impact to summary sentences, so this appears to be a purely front end restriction.

Not sure what my exact suggestion is if it's being stored as one string in the db. Obviously storage changes are a mess; ideally the description could be split to two boxes with individual limits to allow 'normal' tag modification in summary edits, but that could potentially be a not exactly minor change if it's structured as I'm assuming, so I guess I'm just suggesting that you up the maxlength attribute on the edit page and consider a split field in future as a more sweeping solution.

Also kind of curious what would happen if someone deleted the maxlength attribute and really went to town on that box. I don't plan to try it.

Unless I'm completely mistaken and still half-asleep, which is totally possible. In which case carry on.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Would be easy if it did, but I edited my description to 316 characters last night.

EDIT: To clarify, I didn't muck around with the maxlength in add, so if there are restrictions on that behind the scenes then two thumbs up. But on edit, my original description was 290-something characters (I think), exceeding maxlength, so that's affected by the suggestion to increase it here. But I forced in the new tags and description updates, and it successfully saved with 316 characters (154 summary sentences and the rest tags, so I follow the spirit of the add function if not the edit box). So 255 doesn't appear to be a hard limit for edits. Still, I haven't tested the boundaries of that and don't intend to; hopefully it does truncate before it would become a visual issue in the archive if someone did more. Regardless, I think 255 should be higher because tags.

I'm dodging specifics on exactly what I did because I don't want to encourage everyone and their grandmother to try it out, but if you want a step by step, I can try Skype or something.

Edited by EllieMorgan
Link to comment
Share on other sites

In the add story part, which works well since it's separate from tags. Edit details has a concatenated field, something like:

<input type="text" name="sdescrip" value="$concatenated_descrip_and_tags_string" maxlength="255">

After which forcing the field value to something longer than 255 is still accepted on post. It's this maxlength that could be problematic for editing tags/description in longer or more involved fics.

See the story Depravity in http://games.adult-fanfiction.org/main.php?list=1803for exceeding 255.

I'm not very good at describing this, haha.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I counted it, and yes, you have 290 total characters for the summary. HOWEVER, last I checked, the field itself was limited. Having said that, this was a number of years ago. Could be that the main tech actually changed the properties of the field as well. Won't know until I look.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...