draechaeli Posted July 19, 2009 Report Share Posted July 19, 2009 (edited) Physically, psychologically, accurate Harry Potter This is a challenge and a story plot that I endeavour to write. The basis of which is that the implied and abuse that Harry Potter suffered as a child should have been more apparent. For example, Harry should feel awkward with casual touch, or crave it, and he should be small for his age. In many fics these are features that are very apparent. I want to read/write a fic where the first glimpse of Harry it is obvious that he suffered at the Dursley's. I would also not mind write the first one to two chapters under certain parameter so that I write the first glimpse of abused Harry and then let someone else with good plot ideas finish. I would like to see and read more of such stories and for the one that I would like to write I would like to ask peoples options on how they interpreted Harry's life prior to Hogwarts. If as many people as possible could help me with this I would appreciate it. I have two list of questions how you interpreted the books/movies and the second what you like to read. How You Interpreted the Books/Movies 1. On a scale of Neglect to severe mental and physical abuse where is Harry? 2. On a scale of extra chores to slave where is Harry? 3. On a scale of no physical contact to sex slave/whored out where is Harry? 4. On a scale of Malnourishment to Starvation where is Harry? What You Enjoy Reading 1. Would you read this fic where Harry's abuse was more medically realistic and apparent? If so would you only read it if the abuse was minimal, moderate, or savvier, or does that not matter to you? 2. Do you feel that if Harry appeared and acted more like an abuse victim then in the books, would the Wizarding World be blind, only wanting to see their saviour? 3. On a scale of Neglect to severe mental and physical abuse where is Harry? 4. On a scale of extra chores to slave where is Harry? 5. On a scale of no physical contact to sex slave/whored out where is Harry? 6. On a scale of Malnourishment to Starvation where is Harry? 7. MPreg Yay or Nay? 8. Threesome/Moresome Yay or Nay? 9. BDSM Yay or Nay? (you can separate it out too) 10. Slave Yay or Nay? 11. Under 18 Yay or Nay? 11.2. Non-Con Yay or Nay? 12. Dumbledore Yay or Nay? 13. Weasley's Yay or Nay? (you can break it down and differ between members) 14. Hermione Yay or Nay? 15. Malfoy's Yay or Nay? (you can break it down and differ between members) 16. Snape Yay or Nay? 17. Remus Yay or Nay? 18. Sirius Yay or Nay? 19. Fenrir Yay or Nay? 20. Tom Riddle/Voldemort Yay or Nay? (you can separate them) I wouldn't mind also knowing people's favourite pairings. For some clarifying definitions since I often find these words in fics misused here are the dictionary definitions of some terms. Starvation –noun: the act or state of starving; condition of being starved. Malnourished –adjective: poorly or improperly nourished Neglect –verb: to pay no attention or too little attention to; disregard or slight Please also note that I am not saying that neglect is a lesser offence then physical abuse. I am just saying they are on separate ends of the spectrum. If one is truly neglected then one is not also beat. Thanks for your help I appreciate it! Edited July 19, 2009 by draechaeli Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
draechaeli Posted July 19, 2009 Author Report Share Posted July 19, 2009 To be fair I am answering my own questions How You Interpreted the Books/Movies 1. On a scale of Neglect to severe mental and physical abuse where is Harry? Somewhere in the middle 2. On a scale of extra chores to slave where is Harry? more on the slave end 3. On a scale of no physical contact to sex slave/whored out where is Harry? no physical contact 4. On a scale of Malnourishment to Starvation where is Harry? more towards malnourished What You Enjoy Reading 1. Would you read this fic where Harry’s abuse was more medically realistic and apparent? If so would you only read it if the abuse was minimal, moderate, or savvier, or does that not matter to you? Yes I would read it and as long as the abuse was realistic went with a plot and there was some form of resolution I would read it. 2. Do you feel that if Harry appeared and acted more like an abuse victim then in the books, would the Wizarding World be blind, only wanting to see their saviour? Yes 3. On a scale of Neglect to severe mental and physical abuse where is Harry? Anywhere 4. On a scale of extra chores to slave where is Harry? slave, is more fun (brings in new conflict) 5. On a scale of no physical contact to sex slave/whored out where is Harry? Either is good 6. On a scale of Malnourishment to Starvation where is Harry? I really want to write a proper malnourished Harry 7. MPreg Yay or Nay? 8. Threesome/Moresome Yay or Nay? 9. BDSM Yay or Nay? (you can separate it out too) 10. Slave Yay or Nay? 11. Under 18 Yay or Nay? I should have added Non-con to which my answer is to move a plot okay 12. Dumbledore Yay or Nay? 13. Weasley’s Yay or Nay? (you can break it down and differ between members) I love the Twins, Bill and Charlie the rest is a toss up 14. Hermione Yay or Nay? toss up 15. Malfoy’s Yay or Nay? (you can break it down and differ between members) 16. Snape Yay or Nay? 17. Remus Yay or Nay? 18. Sirius Yay or Nay? toss up 19. Fenrir Yay or Nay? toss up 20. Tom Riddle/Voldemort Yay or Nay? (you can separate them) toss up I wouldn’t mind also knowing people’s favourite pairings. It depends on my mood and what I want to read: Draco/Harry Severus/Harry Fenrir/Harry Lucius/Harry Tom/Harry Remus/Sirius/Remus Mix and match the above Fred/George/Fred Ron/Hermione Pansy/Hermione Neville/Ginny Neville/Luna Luna/Ginny Blaise/Ron Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Galactus Posted July 23, 2009 Report Share Posted July 23, 2009 How You Interpreted the Books/Movies 1. On a scale of Neglect to severe mental and physical abuse where is Harry? Definitly abused both ways. Not "A Child Called It" but the Dursley's fucked him up in ways that didn't seem realistically portrayed in the books. 2. On a scale of extra chores to slave where is Harry? Indentured servitude. 3. On a scale of no physical contact to sex slave/whored out where is Harry? In the books; none what so ever. But in my mind I like to think that Dudley held him down with his friends more than once... 4. On a scale of Malnourishment to Starvation where is Harry? Neither. He ate, he just never ate well. What You Enjoy Reading 1. Would you read this fic where Harry's abuse was more medically realistic and apparent? If so would you only read it if the abuse was minimal, moderate, or savvier, or does that not matter to you? As professionally curious as a realistic or more honest approach to Harry's abuse would be I can't really see that being personally readable. 2. Do you feel that if Harry appeared and acted more like an abuse victim then in the books, would the Wizarding World be blind, only wanting to see their saviour? I think they'd see Little Damaged Boy than anything else. Parents murdered, socially retarded, and magically inept? I think they'd feel pity. 3. On a scale of Neglect to severe mental and physical abuse where is Harry? If in terms of what I enjoy reading, harsh mental but mild physical. I'm not into thrashings and such. 4. On a scale of extra chores to slave where is Harry? Oh slave definitely. 5. On a scale of no physical contact to sex slave/whored out where is Harry? I have positively NO interest in seeing Harry raped by Vernon but toyed with by Petunia and victimized by Dudley. Chills friend... 6. On a scale of Malnourishment to Starvation where is Harry? Hunger. 7. MPreg Yay or Nay? Not for this one. 8. Threesome/Moresome Yay or Nay? Dudley pals gang rape. Ka-ching. 9. BDSM Yay or Nay? (you can separate it out too) Yes. Oh yes. 10. Slave Yay or Nay? Yes. 11. Under 18 Yay or Nay? Obviously for this subject. 11.2. Non-Con Yay or Nay? Sorry not familiar with the term. 12. Dumbledore Yay or Nay? No. 13. Weasley's Yay or Nay? (you can break it down and differ between members) I don't see how they relate to this specific topic but yeah, all the damn randy redheads should be on board. 14. Hermione Yay or Nay? Sure why not. Still don't see how she relates to this story tho'. 15. Malfoy's Yay or Nay? (you can break it down and differ between members) Bored with Malfoy slash. 16. Snape Yay or Nay? LOATH Snape slash. 17. Remus Yay or Nay? Nope. 18. Sirius Yay or Nay? Nah. 19. Fenrir Yay or Nay? Uh-uh. 20. Tom Riddle/Voldemort Yay or Nay? (you can separate them) Maybe in a creepy nightmare sitch... I wouldn't mind also knowing people's favourite pairings. Just in terms of Harry Potter U? Harry/Ron Harry/Hermione/Ron Ron/Ginny (futa) Ron/Fred/George (gangrape) Ron/Ginny/Fred/George (What can I say? I love the Weasleys!) Ginny/Hermione Malfoy/Crabbe/Goyle (master/slave) Harry/Dobby (master/slave) Fleur/Ginny Cho/Hermione Harry/Rita Skeeter Hope it helps! Yours, Galactus Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest Lemon-Cake_Overlord Posted August 20, 2012 Report Share Posted August 20, 2012 How You Interpreted the Books/Movies 1. On a scale of Neglect to severe mental and physical abuse where is Harry? Truthfully I beileve it was somewhere in the middle, though leaning more on the neglect side... 2. On a scale of extra chores to slave where is Harry? Slave... 3. On a scale of no physical contact to sex slave/whored out where is Harry? Again I say somewhere in the middle leaning more towards no physical contact 4. On a scale of Malnourishment to Starvation where is Harry? I think Harry was severely malenourished, if I'm not mistaken I believe they said in the books that he was smaller than the other boys his age What You Enjoy Reading 1. Would you read this fic where Harry's abuse was more medically realistic and apparent? If so would you only read it if the abuse was minimal, moderate, or savvier, or does that not matter to you? Depending on my mood it doesn't really matter 2. Do you feel that if Harry appeared and acted more like an abuse victim then in the books, would the Wizarding World be blind, only wanting to see their saviour? Depends the Wizarding world as a whole might only see the Savior though a select group of people might just pity him 3. On a scale of Neglect to severe mental and physical abuse where is Harry? Either or 4. On a scale of extra chores to slave where is Harry? depends on my mood, though usually I like it somewhere in the middle 5. On a scale of no physical contact to sex slave/whored out where is Harry? Somewhere in the middle 6. On a scale of Malnourishment to Starvation where is Harry? either or 7. MPreg Yay or Nay? Though I prefer the partner becoming pregnant 8. Threesome/Moresome Yay or Nay? 9. BDSM Yay or Nay? (you can separate it out too) Depending on how abused Harry is that won't be enjoyable... 10. Slave Yay or Nay? Though Really it depends 11. Under 18 Yay or Nay? 11.2. Non-Con Yay or Nay? Again it depends 12. Dumbledore Yay or Nay? I like it when Dombledore is good and cares for Harry, though still minipulative 13. Weasley's Yay or Nay? (you can break it down and differ between members) 14. Hermione Yay or Nay? 15. Malfoy's Yay or Nay? (you can break it down and differ between members) Not all at once and not right off the back but slowly warm up to Harry with Draco being the first 16. Snape Yay or Nay? In a stand offish sort of way 17. Remus Yay or Nay? In a fatherly sort of way 18. Sirius Yay or Nay? In a fatherly/older brother sort of way 19. Fenrir Yay or Nay? Though really it depends 20. Tom Riddle/Voldemort Yay or Nay? (you can separate them) Though it depends I wouldn't mind also knowing people's favourite pairings. Favourite pairings... Harry/Draco(/Harry) Harry/Ginny (sometimes...) Snape/Harry/Snape Snape/Harry/Draco Snape/Remus Snape/Sirius/Remus Remus/Sirius Remus/Tonks Ron/Hermione Ron/Blaise Zabini Blaise Zabini/Harry Blaise Zanbini/Draco Blaise Zabini/Harry Blaise Zabini/Seamus Finnigan Blaise Zabini/Neville Neville/Ginny Neville/Luna Fred/George Fred/George/Harry and there's more.... Well I hope this is still open for discusion... Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts